BANG! Federal Judge Upholds Trumps Mulvaney Appointment to CFPB


U.S. District Court Judge Timothy Kelly’s decision that allows President Trump’s pick to run the CFPB.

WASHINGTON – A federal judge on Tuesday refused to block the appointment of Mick Mulvaney as interim director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, siding with the Trump administration in the legal fight over the leadership of the consumer watchdog.

“Denying the president’s authority to appoint Mr. Mulvaney raises significant constitutional questions,” U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly said.

“Nothing in the statutes prevents Mr. Mulvaney from holding both of these positions,” the judge said, referring to Mulvaney’s existing job as the federal budget director.

Kelly, a Trump appointee, rejected the argument in a lawsuit from Leandra English that she should be the interim leader of the consumer bureau that oversees banks, mortgage providers, credit card issuers and other financial services that affect millions of Americans.

Richard Cordray, who resigned as the consumer bureau’s director on Friday, elevated English from her job as the watchdog’s chief of staff to deputy director in an 11th-hour appointment as he departed. Cordray said a provision of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform act that created the watchdog after the financial crisis would automatically make her his successor.

President Trump, however, named Mulvaney as the watchdog’s acting director hours later, citing authority from a different federal law called the Vacancies Reform Act. The move set off two days of confusion as both English and Mulvaney claimed to be the bureau’s acting director.

After a lawsuit from English to block Mulvaney from taking over, Kelly ruled that the provisions of the law cited by Trump and Department of Justice attorneys serve as the prevailing authority in support of the president’s “lawful” appointment.

 Deepak Gupta, English’s attorney, acknowledged the court “loss” in a brief statement following the decision. However, he vowed that the ruling would “not be the final answer.” He signaled that the case would move forward with a possible request for a preliminary injunction against Trump’s appointment.

A court denial at that stage would trigger a likely appeal.

At one point during Tuesday’s court session, Gupta raised the possibility that English could face punitive action from Mulvaney for challenging his leadership of the agency.

Kelly, however, said no direct evidence of such retaliation had been presented to the court.

The Trump administration quickly declared victory over the judge’s decision.

“The administration applauds the Court’s decision, which provides further support for the President’s rightful authority to designate Director Mulvaney as Acting Director of the CFPB,” the White House said in a statement.

“It’s time for the Democrats to stop enabling this brazen political stunt by a rogue employee and allow Acting Director Mulvaney to continue the Bureau’s smooth transition into an agency that truly serves to help consumers.”

The Consumer Bankers Association, one of several financial services providers that have criticized the consumer bureau’s actions, similarly welcomed the ruling.

“We look forward to working with Acting CFPB Director Mick Mulvaney to bring transparent and balanced consumer protections to all customers and small businesses,” CBA President and CEO Richard Hunt said in a statement.

The unusual battle for control of the consumer bureau started on Friday as Cordray ended his six-year tenure with the controversial leadership succession plan. On Monday, both English and Mulvaney showed up for work and claimed the mantle as acting director.

The dueling acting directors left the watchdog’s leadership and immediate future in doubt.

Mulvaney issued a directive this week instructing staffers to consider him the acting director. Separately, English sent the employees an email about the succession changes and met with congressional Democrats who supported her claim to the watchdog’s top job.

From the White House’s perspective, Mulvaney’s installation was meant to serve as an immediate break with the Obama-era leadership, pending the nomination and approval of a permanent director.

During a Monday news conference, Mulvaney said that the consumer bureau’s operations under Trump would be “dramatically different” than under Obama.

Referring to Trump’s view of the watchdog’s mission, Mulvaney said: “He wants me to get it back to the point where it can protect people without trampling on capitalism, without choking off the access to financial services that are so critical to so many folks.”

Gupta argued, unsuccessfully, that allowing Mulvaney, a top White House official, to hold the post would compromise the bureau’s independence.

However, Mulvaney insisted he would “be as independent from Donald Trump in this role” as Cordray had been from Obama.

[adrotate banner=”24″]

Great Emigration departs for Oregon

A massive wagon train, made up of 1,000 settlers and 1,000 head of cattle, sets off down the Oregon Trail from Independence, Missouri. Known as the “Great Emigration,” the expedition came two years after the first modest party of settlers ...
Read More

WALSH: The Only Thing Preventing Us From Descending Into Civil War

We’re told that “division” and “partisanship” and “bigotry” are destroying America. “Hate” is the cancer in our cultural bloodstream, they say. We must fight against hate speech and hate crimes and hate in every other form. There is so much ...
Read More

The Surprisingly Solid Mathematical Case of the Tin Foil Hat Gun Prepper Or, “Who Needs an AR-15 Anyway?”

As gun policy discussions unfold in the wake of mass shooter incidents, they routinely end in three buckets. There’s the “tyranny can never happen here” bucket, which the left has mostly abdicated in the wake of Trump winning after they ...
Read More

End of an era at the FBI

After nearly five decades as director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), J. Edgar Hoover dies, leaving the powerful government agency without the administrator who had been largely responsible for its existence and shape. Educated as a lawyer and ...
Read More

Airborne units getting new vehicle this year; legs will have to wait

The Army’s five airborne infantry brigade combat teams are slated to begin fielding 300 Ground Mobility Vehicles in use by special operations forces troops this year. The legs? They’ll get theirs next year, if the funding request is approved. Thirty ...
Read More

British Parliament adopts the Coercive Acts

Upset by the Boston Tea Party and other blatant acts of destruction of British property by American colonists, the British Parliament enacts the Coercive Acts, to the outrage of American Patriots, on this day in 1774.The Coercive Acts were a ...
Read More

Jefferson elected to the Continental Congress

Future President Thomas Jefferson is elected to the second Continental Congress on this day in 1775. Jefferson, a Virginia delegate, quickly established himself in the Continental Congress with the publication of his paper entitled A Summary View of the Rights ...
Read More

7 EMP Proof Items for Your Bugout Bag

This post was gladly contributed by Ben Ayad from Outdorrs Time. There was a time when the world thought the nuclear bomb was as bad as it could get in war. Times have changed, and we know that the one ...
Read More

Parliament passes the Boston Port Act

On this day in 1774, British Parliament passes the Boston Port Act, closing the port of Boston and demanding that the city’s residents pay for the nearly $1 million worth (in today’s money) of tea dumped into Boston Harbor during ...
Read More

[adrotate group="4"]


[adrotate banner="24"]

Most Read Stories

Project Thor

Did the U.S. Just launch “Project Thor” as the secret ZUMA Payload that SpaceX just put into Orbit?

The 107-country Outer Space Treaty signed in 1967 prohibits nuclear, biological, or chemical weapons from being placed or used from Earth’s orbit. What they didn’t count on was the U.S. Air Force’s most simple weapon […]

Police State

With a Stroke of a Pen, PA Governor Wolf Limits Firearm Rights by Proclaiming State of Emergency

Today, Pennsylvania Governor Wolf issued a proclamation declaring Pennsylvania’s heroin and opioid epidemic a statewide disaster emergency, seemingly triggering the firearm prohibitions found in 18 Pa.C.S. § 6107 during declared emergencies. Specifically, Section 6107 provides: (a) General […]

Goodbye Brass

Goodbye, Brass?

by Art Merrill – Monday, February 13, 2017 Let’s skip the appetizer and get right to the meat and potatoes of a manufacturer’s claims for a new cartridge case technology to replace the 150-year reign of […]