What is the Militia ?

Components of the Militia

When asked what the Militia was, George Mason, one of the Framers of the U.S. Constitution, said, “Who are the Militia? They consist now of the whole people, except for a few public officers.” Yet we also see statutes like 10 USC 311, which defines it as “all able- bodied males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section 13 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or have made a declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States.” Some state statutes define it as “able-bodied males” of different age ranges, such as 16 through 59.

These statutes also divide the Militia into various classes, such as “organized” or “unorganized”, in the case of 10 USC 311, or “active” and “reserve”, as many states do, with “active” being considered the National or State Guards, but not the national armed forces.

To understand how these definitions have arisen, one must first understand what the Framers of the U.S. Constitution had in mind for the new Republic they had created. They allowed for a standing national army, but insisted that it be kept small, and although it might be the first force to be called out, and the only force to be sent abroad, the primary defense of the country was to be the duty of ordinary citizens, who would be kept in a state of military readiness while leading their normal lives, and who would be called up to “repel invasions, suppress insurrections, or execute the laws”, for limited periods of time. At the time the Constitution was adopted in 1789, the well-established tradition was for local militia units to be kept in a state of readiness in each and every community. Such units were organized and trained locally, perhaps led by the local town or county officials, but otherwise independent of official control when not actually called up for service.

When lawmakers tried to define the “militia” by statute to consist of less than the entire body of citizens, they were defining those citizens who would be required to be kept in a state of readiness, as was done in the Militia Act of 1792, which required able-bodied males age 17 through 44 to keep a “musket or firelock”. However, persons younger than 18 and older than 45 regularly responded to call-ups of the Militia and were accepted as part of it. There were even some women who participated.

The Framers also insisted on a distinction between the “genuine” Militia and a “select” militia, which they viewed as a danger, just as much a danger as a standing army. They did not want a militia whose members might consist of anything less than the entire people, or at least able-bodied ones in a certain age range, because if selected on any other basis, they might be used to oppress other parts of the population.

Actually, George Mason provided the best definition. It only needs to be broken out into various classes, representing the order in which persons would be called out for military service. Qualifications like “able-bodied” or “male” or “age 18-44” only establish who would be first called to service, with the expectation that they would be adequate for almost any situation, but it allows for calling up other persons if needed.

 

This suggests a hierarchy of classes:

National Army.
Full-time. Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, Coast Guard.
Part-time. Reserves, National Guard.
State and Local Select Militia. But these are not “general” militias. They are paid and equipped by the State or by local governments.

Full-time. State and local law enforcement officers.
Part-time. State Guard.
Obligatory Militia. Able-bodied male citizens of a certain age range, who are required to be kept organized and trained, but at their own expense. Age range is 18-44 for federal purposes, but states may establish other age ranges.

Volunteer Militia. Citizens not part of obligatory militia who voluntarily participate in activities of the obligatory militia, again at their own expense.

Ready Militia. The combination of (3) and (4) above, who would be called up after the armed forces and the regular militia, but who are also those likely to be first on the scene in emergency situations. It is not a “select” militia.

Reserve Militia. All other citizens, including children, the elderly, the less-able, and women, and perhaps foreign visitors as well, who might be called up after the ready militia, if needed.

What is missing from the current picture is the ready militia.

Illinois State Militia 1st Battalion Training

Most states now lump it in with what we are here calling the reserve militia, and in fact often call it that. The ready militia is what the Framers meant when they used the term “militia”. It is also what the Swiss mean by the term, and it was the Swiss model that the Framers had in mind for the United States. The ready militia was to serve as a counterbalance to the armed forces and regular state (select) militias.

It should be noted that the obligatory militia is usually defined to exempt certain public officials, and perhaps persons with certain occupations, whose usual duties are considered essential.

Choice of words can be indicative. 10 USC 311 lumps the ready and reserve militias into what it calls the “unorganized” militia, with the implication that it is to remain unorganized, since no provisions for organizing and training the ready militia are given, contrary to the intent of the Framers.

Militias are local and independent

Often heard are arguments about whether militias are state or national, but the militia, like citizenship, is fundamentally local. We are first and foremost citizens of our local community. The word “citizen” has the same root as the word “city”. Although people may also be concurrently citizens of larger political entities, such as states or the nation, and although those entities may be considered to be composed of their citizens, they are essentially composed of localities, and it is the local community that is the basis for the social contract, although it may be considered to include a certain amount of surrounding territory. Today we would usually identify the locality with the county.

Just as militias are essentially local, so also are they essentially independent of established authorities, since the militia may have to challenge or bypass those authorities if they abuse their authority or fail to perform their lawful duties.

The legal basis for assemblies of militias are two natural rights: the right to assemble and the right to keep and bear arms. Combined, they are the right to assemble bearing arms. The Framers considered it obvious that rights which could be exercised separately could be exercised in combination, and would have thought present attempts to outlaw independent assemblies of militia units as absurd. The term “well-regulated” used in the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution did not mean “regulated by some official”. It meant “well-trained and disciplined”. A militia can and should be self-regulated.

The U.S. Constitution, in Article I Section 8, does provide for States to organize and train their militias according to standards established by the U.S. Congress, and to appoint the officers, but it was not the intention of that clause to authorize states to forbid local organization and training of militia units, but to require that they be organized and trained. If the state fails to do so, people have not only the right but the duty to organize and train themselves locally, using their own arms. Just as they have the right and duty, failing action on the state level, to conduct elections, enforce the laws, establish courts, and so forth.

Of course, a militia unit that is not called up by any official, but by its own members, does not have the authority to compel participation through some kind of sanction, such as the imposition of a fine. Therefore it will be composed of volunteers, who may not represent a cross-section of the general population. In this situation, the militia members must make a special effort to avoid having the militia unit take on the attributes of a private association, such as by always calling up the militia using public notices, and allowing any responsible citizen to participate. It must also avoid any suggestion of partisan or sectarian bias, and limit itself to constitutional actions.

To do this, a militia unit should always refer to itself as the “[state/county] militia” and not adopt a name that would suggest some kind of private association, something that would expose its members to legal action against it as a legal “person” or as a “conspiracy”. There can’t be a conspiracy of the entire population of an area, and a court can’t serve the entire population with process, even if not all of them are present at meetings.

Organizing strategy

Militia units of 50-200 members should be organized at the local level, by going house by house, covering entire neighborhoods, towns, and counties.

This will initially be easier to do in rural areas, where people are already more receptive to the patriotic message. In urban areas, it may work better to start by organizing “neighborhood associations”, then educating the members gradually until it can be converted into a self-conscious militia unit.

Co-ordination among local units should be done using correspondence committees, which is the traditional method. These committees do not attempt to act as regional,, state, or national organizations, but only to facilitate communications among local units, the sharing of literature, and the building of a consensus for action.

Some units might try to publish newsletters or other documents, but in most cases, it will be better to publish through established magazines and various alternative media, and distribute extra copies. Members may agree to subscribe to media that co-operate in publishing supporting materials.

Dealing with official resistance

For some time now the Establishment has discouraged the formation of armed groups, including independent constitutional militias. They don’t want the “unorganized” militia to become organized. Besides legal and illegal harassment, militia leaders must prepare participants to deal with attempts to infiltrate militia units. This can take three main forms:

Moles. Agents who pretend to be trustworthy but who are mainly focused on obtaining information about militia members and their activities.

Provocators. Agents who pretend to be responsible members, then, when least expected, do something which seeks to discredit the militia and perhaps provoke official action against it.

Dissipators. Agents who pretend commitment until they can assume positions of influence within the group, then use it to divert them into ineffective or unproductive activities, such as endless debate, socializing, and divisive disputes, or to reduce morale and resolve.

The best protection against infiltration is to teach members to be vigilant to it and to have a large number of small units and many leaders, none of whom is critical. There should be little or no leadership on the state or national level, other than a network of correspondence committees that facilitate communications.

It is also important to try to establish good relations with local and state officials, to the extent possible. Work with them to help them solve the problems of the community, and encourage them to ask the militia to assist them. Resistance from such officials should be countered by getting better ones elected or appointed.

Subjects for action

One of the most important subjects for action by local militia units is investigation of election fraud and other kinds of official corruption. It will do little good to try to elect better officials if elections are rigged, and if they are, the militia may become the only way for citizens to secure their rights. If such fraud is found, it will also help to build public support for further militia action and for greater participation.

Another key subject is to inform citizens of their right and duty, when serving as jurors in cases in which the government is a party, to judge the law and not just the facts in the case. No matter how despicable the defendant in a criminal case or how heinous the offense, the jury must find the defendant not guilty if the law under which he is charged is unconstitutional or misapplied. It is unconstitutional if it violates a constitutional right, is not based on a power delegated to government, or is so vague that honest people may disagree on how to obey or enforce it. It is misapplied if it is applied to acts outside its proper jurisdiction, such as a federal criminal law applied to acts committed on state territory, or to acts not intended to be included by the lawmakers.

One of the most important subjects for action will be to establish an alert system for warning of abuses of citizens by organs of the government, and mobilizing to defend them. It must be emphasized that it is not enough for citizens to defend their rights in isolation. Only if they band together can their rights be protected.

Education in constitutional law must also be a priority. Every citizen must be trained to interpret the constitutionality of laws and official acts, and taught that doing so is the responsibility of each individual, that it cannot be delegated to others, such as judges or superiors. That is the Lesson of Nuremberg. Special attention needs to be given to educating lawyers, judges, officials, and college and high school students. Militia members need to make sure that every public library contains suitable books and magazines that provide education on these subjects.

Copyright (C) 1994 Constitution Society. Permission is hereby granted to copy with attribution for noncommercial purposes.

References:

Morgan Norval, ed., The Militia in 20th Century America: A Symposium, 1985, available from Gun Owners Foundation, 5881 Leesburg Pike, Falls Church, VA 22041.
Stephen P. Halbrook, That Every Man Be Armed, 1984, available from the Independent Institute, 134 98th Ave, Oakland, CA 94603.
James M. & Kenneth F. Collier, Votescam: The Stealing of America, 1992, available from Victoria House Press, 67 Wall St #2411, New York, NY 10005.

standing concealed carry 1

BREAKING: House Passes Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act

The House passed legislation to permit concealed carry license holders to conceal a handgun in other states, the first time Congress has taken action on a gun bill since President Donald Trump was sworn into office. The “Concealed Carry Reciprocity ...
Read More
Justice for KATE STEINLE

How to Report Illegal Aliens

Under federal law, any non-U.S. citizen is an alien. Aliens who have entered the United States without permission, or who have violated the terms of their admission, are identified under the law as illegal aliens. That is a fact, not ...
Read More
Immigration Raid

Chicago Immigration Raid Creates 800 New Jobs for Americans at Cloverhill Bakery

A Swiss maker of hamburger buns for McDonald’s Corp. said it’s struggling to run a Chicago bakery after it lost a third of its workers in a clampdown on 800 immigrants without sufficient documentation. About 35 percent of the workers at Cloverhill Bakery had to ...
Read More
Concealed Carry

National Reciprocity for Concealed Carry Passes, Next Stop House Floor

National reciprocity for concealed carry passed the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday is expected to receive a floor vote before the end of the year. The Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act of 2017 was introduced by Rep. Richard Hudson (R-NC) on January 3, 2017. It ...
Read More
Mount Agung

Bali’s Airport Reopens Temporarily while Volcano Continues to Spew Ash

The airport on Indonesia’s major tourist island of Bali has temporarily reopened after a three-day shutdown, even as an erupting volcano continues to spew ash, blocking flight paths and prompting evacuation calls. Shortly after officials had extended closure of the ...
Read More
Christmas in the White House

CHRISTMAS IN THE WHITE HOUSE: This Year Many Americans Will Rest Easier Knowing God is Welcome in the White House

WASHINGTON (AP) — The White House unveiled a Christmas Trailer featuring the First Lady, that seems to shout Oh Joyous Season, as Trump makes it clear that Christmas is Back in America.  Ballerinas leaping to the strains of Tchaikovsky’s “The Nutcracker” ...
Read More
DF 41

China conducts new test of MACH 25 ICBM capable of striking anywhere on earth

China unveils 19,030mph HYPERSONIC scattergun nuke to strike ‘ANYWHERE in world’ China will in the first half of next year becapable of deploying the longest-range nuclear missiles in the world, with a range of up to 15,000km. Major General Xu ...
Read More
Rail Gun

Navy Rail Gun uses electromagnets to shoot projectile 100 miles at mach 7 !

The U.S. Navy’s experimental rail gun is getting new upgrades to make it fire more powerful shots, and fire them faster. It’s the latest bit of progress on this still-landlocked weapon, but when and where it actually would be installed ...
Read More
John Wayne

The History of Taps, and Narration by John Wayne

The Origins of Taps The origins of “Taps,” the distinctive bugle melody played at U.S. military funerals and memorials and as a lights-out signal to soldiers at night, date back to the American Civil War. In July 1862, U.S. General ...
Read More
Jeff Sessions

AG SESSIONS HEARING: Dems say investigation of Dem Crimes is off limits

Oh this is interesting.  John Conyers in the AG Sessions testimony before the Judiciary Committee is attempting to twist the hearing to imply that in looking into Clinton crimes, that the President and Justice Department are wielding their power to ...
Read More
The Pledge Red Skelton

Red Skelton’s heartfelt explanation of the meaning of The Pledge of Allegiance

Red Skelton – What the Pledge means to ME Minute Script: In 1969, Red Skelton gave his personal view of the Pledge of Allegiance. The statement he made at the end, I think, tells it all.Red Skelton, one of America’s ...
Read More
Star spangled banner

The truly amazing story of how Francis Scott Key came to write the Star Spangled Banner

The below video is an moving history of our National Anthem. There are times in life where the task at hand is bigger that one mans life. And there is no more power or honor in that, than when one see’s ...
Read More
Pray

A message to people of all faiths – Now more than ever. Pray for America

At a time when the war on religion seems more open than ever. Where New York’s anti conservative Governor Andrew Cuomo says we should leave the the prayers for Texas shooting victims to Priests and Rabbi’s, East Catholic High Schools ...
Read More

John F. Kennedy -The President and the Responsibility of the Press

On April 27th, 1961, Then President John F. Kennedy gave a speech to newspapers and publishers at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel, in New York City While this speech has been quoted out of context for a variety of purposes, it’s an ...
Read More
Copper Colin Kaepernick

Controversial Coppers’ Colin Kaepernick costume catches criticism

A University of Nevada, Reno police officer is under fire for what some have called an insensitive or racist costume. Antonio Gutierrez, pictured above apparently attended a Halloween Party dressed as beleaguered NFL Quarterback, Colin Kaepernick, wearing a 49’ers jersey, a ...
Read More

Illegal Immigrants Jump Fence on LIVE TV !

Amazingly you can’t make this stuff up. While broadcasting a live piece on Trumps boarder wall, illegal immigrants ride up on horseback and jump the fence! Like this:Like Loading... Related ...
Read More

National Anthem ….. with percussion.

Well that’s certainly unique, and in that spirit I can only say …. God Bless America. National Anthem Like this:Like Loading... Related ...
Read More
Pamela Gaudy National Anthem

Airline tells passengers they cannot sing The National Anthem for Fallen Hero

Delta airline passengers were informed that there was an deceased American Soldier on board, being accompanied home by his best friend also a soldier in uniform. When the passengers decide to sing the National Anthem to honor the fallen soldier ...
Read More
One Nation Under God

These United States, One Nation Under God and the Spirit of Nationalism

If you don’t understand Nationalist. Think of it this way. You can be the United States of America, or you can be the United States of Earth, but if you are the United States of Earth, UN Rules apply, and ...
Read More
Baofeng Radios

Best low cost communication starter gear. Baofeng Radios UV-5r, GT-3TP

Your HT (Handie Talkie) is going to be your first important communications purchase. Forget about regular walkie talkies or FRS radios, they are restricted to transmitting on a half a watt only. You can also get paired MURS radios, but ...
Read More
Erasing the lessons of history

Erasing the lessons of History

What is happening today in the EU may be worse than watching an iron curtain fall across Eastern Europe.  The one thing that has made Western Europe great, was its long rich history, culture and rule of law. What we ...
Read More
Antifa

Antifa – The Undoing of the Left

Antifa – The Undoing of the Left FROG IN BOILING WATER It has been said that the state of America is analogous to the frog in boiling water story. The premise is that if a frog is put suddenly into ...
Read More

What is the Militia ?

Components of the Militia When asked what the Militia was, George Mason, one of the Framers of the U.S. Constitution, said, “Who are the Militia? They consist now of the whole people, except for a few public officers.” Yet we ...
Read More
12 Gauge

12 gauge home defense – Mossberg and Remington Platforms

While there may be a lot of discussion and choices on that first home defense gun, invariably the discussion will circle back around to the good old 12ga shotgun. A shotgun, is one of the most versatile weapons in your ...
Read More
Just in time inventory

72 hours – A “just in time inventory system” on the brink of chaos

Just in time inventory is a business model used by almost every retailer these days. Fuel, automobile parts, medicines, and grocery stores operate on a just in time inventory system. What this means is that in order to keep costs down, they ...
Read More
Wilderness First Aid

Wilderness First Aid

 General thoughts on First Aid and Survival in the back country Wilderness is described as any area in which a person may be an hour or more from any modern conveniences, or medical attention. Wilderness First Aid In a typical ...
Read More

Tactical Medicine

The EMS subspecialty of tactical medicine and the role of the tactical medic is not a new concept. Bringing medical intervention to the arena of battle predates Napoleon’s directive for having an ambulance near the front lines in the event he himself was ...
Read More